| Original message (2977 Views )
|
Replies: |
| Pollyanna 1436th Post
 
Red Carpet Executive Member
    
    
    
    
|  "Re(1):What's so good about Dragon Quest games" , posted Tue 27 Sep 09:20
Which "RPGs of the time" are you comparing it to? FF5?
The DQ games just have charm. I think that's it. I mean, the systems usually work well enough, the enemy designs are fun and the music is beyond amazing. (excluding the only decent DQ8 soundtrack)
These are all good things, but I don't think they account for the popularity as much as having a game that retains the same charm that "old school" RPGs have. So many people don't like "new" RPGs and complain that they want more "old school" despite the fact that the characters were often bland, the stories were predictable and the systems were limited. However, the intangible charm is still there.
The only DQ I really liked was 7, because it gave you so much to do, was challenging, had a good job system, an excellent soundtrack, great subplots and mostly likable characters. Of course, it still had its share of problems...
|
| ONSLAUGHT 3523th Post
Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master
    
| "Re(1):What's so good about Dragon Quest games" , posted Tue 27 Sep 14:27
quote:
Toriyama designs?
While I think some of the Toriyama's designs are very cool (Piccolo, Freezer, Cell, Janemba, Magus, for example), I find most of them boring, repetitive and uninspired. I've never played a DQ, but I bet there's always a Goku, Bulma, Piccolo, a weird bubble shaped robot, and so on.
What's the appeal on Toriyama's designs anyway?
|
| Time Mage 2255th Post
Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master
| "Re(5):What's so good about Dragon Quest games" , posted Tue 27 Sep 23:04
quote:
It's really just a matter of numbers. You play to have more of this, then more of that, for the sole purpose of having more of that. It has that strange power MMORPG have.
Ugh, is that so? I'm not a fan of amassing numbers. Skills, weapons, or other more meaningful things, yes, but not numbers: I hate leveling.
Anyway, if I've asked specifically about Toriyama is because, as Polly said, the games seem to revolve around his designs. It's true that many of his human designs are bland, but even some of those have charm in my opinion.
None of you have mentioned the story. Are the stories so bad/uninteresting?
Oh, and I was comparing DQ6 system to Chrono Trigger and FF6 (which also has a simple system, but not as simple). I don't know if other DQ games will have a better ability system, but what I read about DQ6 seemed a bit limited.
|
| aderack
172th Post
Regular Customer
| "Re(6):What's so good about Dragon Quest games" , posted Tue 27 Sep 23:38:
There's no nonsense to them. Keep in mind every other JRPG is a Dragon Quest clone, and has to contrive something to set itself apart from Dragon Quest. Draon Quest is, therefore, the fundamental game that everything else is a deviation from.
And there is a certain purity and wholeness to it, as an experience. It's balanced for a certain sense of immediacy: all that matters is right now.
For the most part, the game realizes where its abstractions are and that they are abstractions. Although it's mostly just statistics, fighting means something in and of itself: the stronger you get, the further you can safely explore. The larger your world becomes. It's a barrier you must butt heads with if you want to grow. Nothing to glory in; it's just a fact. This is compared to most RPGs where you fight to make it easier to beat upcoming bosses, or to level up for the sake of levelling up, or where fighting appears to be the whole point, for whatever reason, rather than a mere fact of exploration in dangerous places -- and where you move forward to get to the next area and forward the plot and finish the game.
Its simplicity and its honestness really drive home how most other JPRGs have missed the point -- by slapping on extra systems, extra layers of complexity just to make themselves different, trinkets, fetishes, by taking literally things that were abstract for a reason (like the numbers, or the concept of an "overworld"), by putting the focus on petty issues rather than practical ones.
When it comes down to it, Dragon Quest is about growing up, maturing, seeing the world. Experience has meaning, because the more experience you have the broader your world becomes. Money is practical because it allows you buy tools to help you in your travels.
You will constantly be hitting your head against your limit and being forced to go home, rest, recuperate. The next day you go out and hit the world again, a little wiser, a little stronger. Maybe today you'll see something you never saw before.
That's more or less the focus of every game. DQ8 makes it more clear by making trees trees, making mountains mountains, giving you a horizon and putting things on it to inspire you to go out and look for them. You will still keep having to go home. Stray too far, too quickly, and you will get in over your head and you will be in trouble. And you might just get killed. Yet that danger just adds all the more excitement to every day's travel.
Curiously, if you can get around the interface issues (like having to choose "stairs" from a menu every time you want to climb them), the original Dragon Warrior has hardly dated at all. Again, that's just a matter of the game's fundamental simplicity. It's like playing Super Mario Bros. or Asteroids. They're all complete, as far as they go. Not as complex as current games, but so what. What's complexity other than complexity. Compare that to Final Fantasy 1, which is pretty much unplayable by current standards. It just doesn't know what it's doing, or -- more importantly -- why it's doing what it does.
When it comes down to it, playing Dragon Quest is a meditative experience. In Dragon Quest, things just Are. When you play, you just Are. It's a game about Being. There's no real goal; anything that the game might throw at you is a MacGuffin, really. Something to get you out the door. It's a joyous game, a little melancholy, all about the patterns of life and change while always remaining the same. It's happy simply to exist, and do what it does because that's what it was put there to do. No ambition. No glory. No drama. Just a quest. A quest after dragons.
[this message was edited by aderack on Wed 28 Sep 00:29] |
| Maese Spt
15th Post
New Customer
| "the importance of being Toriyama" , posted Wed 28 Sep 20:22
quote:
Anyway, if I've asked specifically about Toriyama is because, as Polly said, the games seem to revolve around his designs. It's true that many of his human designs are bland, but even some of those have charm in my opinion.
I think Toriyama´s designs have much to do in DQ´success. He began doing this stuff when he was almost at the top of his popularity in Japan and, AFAIK, he was the first manga artist in doing character designs for a videogame. Besides being a most innovative strategy, I guess this hyped Arale and Dragon Ball fans, wich were a huge target audience for the game, and thus DQ became a hit. Enix did a fairly good marketing job in my opinion.
Since I haven´t played a single DQ I really don´t know about the virtues of the games, though. I can only guess, but I´ve always believed that Enix was sharp enough to choose the right man at the right moment to make the game as appealing as they could get. Despite other factors, I think that was the key of the franchise´s success.
"Fashion is a form of ugliness so intolerable that we have to alter it every six months"
|
|
|
"Re(6):What's so good about Dragon Quest games" , posted Tue 27 Sep 23:34
Z80 AND SH-2 HEART ON FIRE !!
